Sightings in SaaS

Several articles in the press and blogosphere recently have caused me to stop and think about the future of SaaS, software as a service, and NetSuite as well, one the earliest SaaS adoptors.

First, let me say that SaaS metamorphosed over the past few years from a novel, even radical, idea and market disruptor to a mainstream technology component, one of many that companies of all sizes must consider. When we first started to blog many years ago we considered ourselves SaaS evangelists out on the frontier. Now we are just mainstream preachers and the flock is also more mainstream. Things change.

Witness this article by fellow Enterprise Irregular Phil Wainwright. Phil makes the point that NetSuite has now started to market its integrated suite differently:

Perhaps more SaaS vendors should take a leaf out of NetSuite’s book. Instead of going on about the lower cost and faster time-to-live of their solutions compared to conventional software, they should just point out that operating in the cloud is how business is done these days, and anyone whose business systems operate anywhere else is going to get left behind. It’s as simple as that.

There’s some truth here but it still seems hard to believe that we have now passed the tipping point for SaaS over on-premise software. But one wonders how this will flesh out over time. I don’t think that a lot of the large organizations that run Oracle, SAP, Peoplesoft, etc. are racing to rip and replace. The implementations of these products are not even finished in many cases and that is after years of effort.  As I have written in the past, many of these systems are mere shadows of what they could be but management has seen so many budget and timeline overruns that they are very tentative to continue. On the other hand they have no appetite for declaring defeat either, especially to the board and the market. So they continue to pay the big bucks in annual maintenance and keep a low profile.

NetSuite has taken an interesting tack here, and perhaps it was born of necessity, but going after the small divisions of large enterprises running SAP and offering discount prices (= SAP Maintenance $) is good marketing and will eventually create a situation where NetSuite can surround SAP  and convince management through use and adoption while at the same time continuing to mature as a software offering. NetSuite has made no secret of making SAP in hte mid-market their target.

Apart from this SAP strategy NetSuite is also taking aim at the services market, with the goal of creating a Service Resource Planning suite, SRP, to rival in the services market what SAP did in the products market. NetSuite has already made two acquisitions on the on-demand Professional Services Automation, PSA, market: Open Air and QuickArrow. The best of both of these companys’ offerings will play a role in the final product, I’m betting. CEO Zach Nelson drops a hint here. The bottom line is that NetSuite looks to move upmarket. After starting as NetLedger they have now a strategy in place that will over time move them into some very large enterprises.

Taking all of this in you start to see a market disruption, SaaS, coming together as a series of well planned strategies to build up into the market, each small step leading to the next. This is happening not only in the ERP/CRM space but also across the SaaS space  – HR, CRM, E2.0 social enterprise tools, etc. This is very different from the strategy that Oracle and SAP used to go to market in the original ERP invasion of the 90’s. Supposedly SAP worked on their software for 20 years before bringing it to the market, and they went directly at the largest enterprises. They seem to have a similar approach with their SaaS offering which they’ve been tuning now for three years, running the risk of running out of people’s patience.

Oracle also started out aiming at the largest enterprises. I have to laugh when I think of my nine year career with Oracle. The software that we really needed on my first implementation in 1997 was finally ready 9 years later on my last implementation – a single time entry system that could feed payroll for employee wages and projects for billing and costing. I was the first to implement it for multiple modules.

NetSuite and other SaaS vendors are starting with less functionality and smaller enterprises and then rolling out more functionality as they move up in the market space. NetSuite’s stated goal is to become the SAP of the midmarket, and it is well on its way. SuccessFactors, another SaaS vendor,  just sold a huge deal to Seimens AG in the HR space. 

The point here is that SaaS vendors have necessarily rolled out sounder software, more methodically, than their predecessors. But the march of more and better functionality has become relentless. This is how they will finally beat a lot of the on-premise software vendors.  The tipping point will go by quite unnoticed, unless of course we keep someone at the front who calls out ‘tipping point’ every fifteen minutes or so.  It will be a fairly quiet revolution. Conventional software will go out not with a bang but a whimper.

One Response to “Whither NetSuite? Whither SaaS?”